What does it mean to be a human or part of the human race? What is humanity? Are humans animals? Where does one draw the line? What makes us distinct from the animal kingdom?
Often times when faced with the reality of violent human conflicts, one ends up concluding that humans are all animals. What does this mean? That we are savage, violent, void of emotion and compassion? I almost never see crude violence around me everyday in my immediate environment. So does this make only some humans more animal-like than others? What is the difference really? I think there needs to be another word invented for “our species”- something that is between a human and an animal. Maybe we can call ourselves Animanes?
Let me explain myself a little more. Most would generally agree that the main characteristic that distinguishes us from animals is our elevated capacity to use our brains. This implies our capacity to engage in the creative process to invent things, to find solutions to problems, to express intense emotions, to think profoundly and try to understand that which is beyond our current reality- the metaphysical or supernatural world. No other animal, besides the human (at least to our current knowledge) has been able to demonstrate similar characteristics to such a degree. So if humans are the only ones that have such major characteristics that differentiate them from the rest of the animal kingdom, why is it that we still fall in the animal category? We only refer to humans as animals once they tend to show their human side less. Obviously, humans are placed from one end of the “Humane/Animal” spectrum to the other. So why don’t we create another word in between? Something that defines us as animals but still capable of being human?
This can explain our capacity to change from one end to the other depending on our environment. This is our delicate and dangerous position as “intellectually advanced animals” capable of acting as savage animals however with the advantage of using our intellect to cause even greater damage. The creation of nuclear arms can be a prime example of this. I think if we were to create another name to describe “our kind” some of us would be more tempted to reach the category of ‘human’. It would be clearer to us that we have a choice to either be more animal-like to being more human-like. For now, we assume that humans are just animals- justifying our use for violence, our acts of greed, revenge and selfishness. We often ignore the fact that as humans we also have an immense capacity for compassion, emotional understanding, and support even under the most difficult situations. We can surpass these ugly “animal-like qualities” if we work hard enough to develop them.
It’s incredible how we can be capable of switching our minds completely. One minute you can be living life filled with love, compassion for others, interest in developing your life and your society. But then let’s say a war breaks out. Suddenly you are faced with constant violence around you, with divisions, categorizations and a threat to your survival. With no escape- it becomes nearly impossible to hold on to your humanity. I remember a conversation I had once with one of my friend’s aunts who lives in the south of Lebanon. She lived there through the civil war, through the several conflicts with Israel in the region, including the most recent confrontation they had with Hezbollah. She said “It doesn’t matter if you don’t want to be part of politics of the conflict- you have no choice! If you want to be neutral, people despise you for it and you are considered an enemy by all sides.” With this mentality, you are obliged to be part of the violent momentum around you. This is exactly how military groups are formed. Either you join or you die. Either you lose your humanity or you die. Most people choose to lose their humanity.
That’s how we end up many times with these vicious military commanders who perform unbelievably grotesque actions against humanity. These are humans who have been conditioned to appease to their savage animal side- making them capable of killing hundreds of people around them. I was reading a book written by Mia Ghoussoub (Leaving Beirut). She gave a very telling excerpt of an ex-war criminal’s testimony:
Hannah Arendt repeats a dialogue recorded by an American journalist in Nov. 1944
Q: Did you kill people in the camp?
A: Yes.
Q: Did you poison them with gas?
A: Yes.
Q: Did you bury them alive?
A: It sometimes happened.
Q: Were the victims picked from all over Europe?
A: I suppose so.
Q: Did you personally help kill people?
A: Absolutely not, I was only paymaster in the camp.
Q: What did you think of what was going on?
A: It was bad at first but we got used to it.
Q: Do you know the Russians will hang you?
A: (Bursting into tears) Why should they? What have I done?
That’s how we can become completely desensitized- completely disconnected with our humanity. Shortly after having read this passage I saw the Francis Bacon expo and found it interesting that one of the greatest themes in his art was his comparison of humans as animals. He believed that without God, man was susceptible to the same tendencies as animals. For this reason, he often made comparisons in his art to humans’ animal instinct. Above is his painting: "The Body, the Meat and the Spirit: Becoming Animal"














.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)



